What a long, strange trip it's been for health care reform in California. After a yearlong effort ABX1-1, the health care bill backed by California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Assembly Speaker Fabian Núñez, has been voted down. The Senate Health Committee delivered a coup de grace in the form of a 7-1 vote against the measure, including a nay vote from Senate President Pro Tem Don Perata (D – Oakland) who originally co-authored the measure.
Rhonda Rundle at the Wall Street Journal talks about the factors that lead to this turnaround (page A9 if you prefer hardcopy):
Support began to erode in the senate as the outlines of the state's $14 billion budget deficit came into focus late last year.ABC News 10, a California news station that covers Sacramento and the surrounding areas, brings us the view from the Chair as reported by Ayesha Thomas:
Last week, the Legislature's nonpartisan fiscal analyst raised questions about funding for the package, further undermining its prospects. Lawmakers who had been leaning in favor of the negotiated bill began backing away in the face of uncertainty about how the state could enact an ambitious new program at a time of fiscal crisis when the governor has proposed cutting funds for established health-care programs.
Committee Chair Shiela Kuehl said there isn't enough money to fund the program.There's more where that came from. The News 10 article ends with a transcription of Gov. Schwarzenegger's Statement in response to the vote.
"There's insufficient funding there for so called subsidies, there's insufficient money there to cover the expanded Medi-Cal coverage," said Kuehl.
"If the headline is Health Committee kills reform, that's an erroneous headline. But we'll live with it...The right headline is Senate Health Committee does not pass bad bill," Kuehl added.
Since this is a California issue a visit to Brian Katz's blog is order. As usual Mr. Katz delivers the goods, this time in the form of this quote from Senator Perata explaining his decision:
In a letter to Governor Schwarzenegger and Speaker Nunez, Senator Perata wrote, “This bill – which is before the Senate, and the initiative, which is not – would create the third-largest program in state government, surpassed only by K-12 education and Medi-Cal. Under any circumstances, but especially in light of the state’s $14.5 billion budget shortfall, we have the fiduciary responsibility to approve a health care coverage plan that is both self financing and fiscally sound and a moral responsibility to protect from harm those who already have health care coverage.”Mr. Katz provides our summation today, as he has stated it so eloquently.
The defeat of ABX1-1 is no cause for celebration. The reality is, while the health care system works well for many in the state, serious problems exist that need to be addressed. With the defeat of ABX1-1, pressure for change will continue to build. Lawmakers may succumb to the pressure to pass anything in order to have passed something.
SOURCE: "Health-Care Bill Fails to Pass" 01/29/08
SOURCE: "Key Committee Rejects Schwarzenegger's Health Reform Effort" 01/29/08
photo courtesy of d_vdm, used under this Creative Commons license